You've been meditating consistently, maybe intensively. Then something shifts—not toward peace but toward darkness. Anxiety that won't lift. Depression without obvious cause. Existential dread. A sense that something is fundamentally wrong. The practice that was supposed to help seems to have opened a door you can't close.
This territory is often called the "dark night"—a term borrowed from Christian mysticism and applied to certain difficult stages in meditation practice. Here's what it is, what it isn't, and what to do if you're in it.
What Is the Dark Night?
The Traditional Context
Christian mysticism: St. John of the Cross wrote "Dark Night of the Soul" describing a stage where God seems absent, spiritual consolation withdraws, and the practitioner experiences profound purification through suffering.
Buddhist maps: In Theravada Buddhism, the "dukkha nanas" (insight knowledges of suffering) describe stages where the meditator perceives dissolution, fear, misery, and disgust as part of the progress of insight.
The common thread: Multiple contemplative traditions describe difficult stages that arise through intensive practice—not as pathology but as part of the path.
The Experience
Common features: - Persistent anxiety or fear - Depression without external cause - Existential meaninglessness - Sense that something is fundamentally wrong - Loss of motivation or interest - Perceptual changes (things seem unreal, flat, or strange) - Physical symptoms (tension, energy disturbances) - Sense that there's no way out
The duration: Can last weeks, months, or in some cases years.
The intensity: Ranges from uncomfortable to severely debilitating.
What It's Not
Not ordinary depression: Though it shares features, the dark night typically arises from practice and has specific phenomenology.
Not failure: In traditional maps, this is progress—uncomfortable progress, but forward movement.
Not permanent: It's a stage, not a destination. Practitioners move through it.
Not everyone's experience: Many meditators never encounter this. Intensive practice increases likelihood.
Why It Happens
Seeing Impermanence Too Clearly
The insight: Everything is constantly changing, dissolving, arising and passing.
The impact: Before this is fully integrated, it can feel terrifying. The ground disappears.
The stage: In Buddhist maps, this relates to the "knowledge of dissolution" where the meditator sees everything falling apart.
Encountering Suffering Directly
The insight: Life involves suffering. This isn't philosophical—it's directly perceived.
The impact: The pervasiveness of suffering, seen clearly, can be overwhelming.
The stage: The "knowledge of suffering" where dukkha is recognized everywhere.
Self Becoming Unstable
The insight: The sense of solid, permanent self is a construction.
The impact: As this becomes experientially apparent, it can feel like annihilation.
The disorientation: Who you thought you were starts to dissolve.
Intensive Practice
The catalyst: Retreats, long sits, committed daily practice can accelerate progress—including progress into difficult territory.
The speed: Material that might surface gradually gets compressed.
The intensity: Concentrated practice produces concentrated experience.
Inadequate Integration
The imbalance: Insight without sufficient stability, ethics, or psychological health can destabilize.
The context: Traditional practice included community, teachers, and lifestyle that supported difficult stages.
The modern problem: Many practitioners have insight practices without support structures.
Is This the Dark Night?
Likely Indicators
Practice correlation: Difficulties began during or after intensive practice.
Specific phenomenology: Perceptual changes, dissolution experiences, existential themes.
Doesn't respond to usual interventions: Rest, distraction, ordinary therapy don't resolve it.
Contemplative flavor: It feels connected to practice, to seeing reality, to meditation themes.
Less Likely Indicators
Pre-existing conditions: If you had anxiety or depression before meditation, this may be that—not dark night.
Life circumstances: If difficulties match external events (loss, stress, change), that's the more likely cause.
No significant practice: Casual meditators rarely encounter this. It typically requires substantial practice.
Ordinary symptoms: If it feels like regular depression or anxiety without contemplative features, it may be regular depression or anxiety.
The Importance of Distinction
Why it matters: Dark night and mental illness require different approaches.
The overlap: They can co-exist. Practice can trigger pre-existing vulnerabilities.
The assessment: Getting help from those who understand both is valuable.
What to Do If You're In It
Find Qualified Support
Who understands: - Teachers familiar with these stages - Therapists who understand meditation - Communities with contemplative experience
What they offer: Context, guidance, normalization, skillful recommendations.
The priority: Don't try to navigate this alone, especially if it's severe.
Adjust Practice
Options include:
Reduce intensity: Shorter sessions, less frequency, less concentration.
Ground the practice: Body-based practices, metta, breath—less insight-oriented work.
Take breaks: Sometimes stepping back from practice helps integration.
Continue carefully: Some teachers advise continuing through with appropriate support.
The guidance: This is where a teacher is essential. Generic advice may not fit your situation.
Support Mental Health
The basics: Sleep, exercise, nutrition, social connection, routine.
Professional help: Therapy, possibly medication if symptoms are severe.
The integration: Treating symptoms while understanding the contemplative context.
Reframe the Experience
The understanding: In traditional frameworks, this is progress, not pathology.
The patience: This stage passes. Others have moved through it.
The meaning: The dissolution of old patterns, while painful, creates room for new understanding.
Community and Connection
The isolation: Dark night often comes with withdrawal and alienation.
The antidote: Connection with others, especially those who understand.
The support: You don't have to do this alone.
Daily Life Emphasis
The grounding: Focus on ordinary life—work, relationships, physical activity.
The balance: Don't disappear entirely into contemplative territory.
The integration: Let insights integrate through living, not just sitting.
Traditional Wisdom
It's Part of the Path
The maps: Every tradition that describes deep practice describes difficult passages.
The normalcy: This isn't deviation from the path—it's the path.
The progress: In Buddhist maps, the dukkha nanas come before the peaceful stages.
It Passes
The stages: Traditional maps show progression through and beyond difficulty.
The evidence: Countless practitioners have moved through this.
The faith: Even when it feels permanent, it isn't.
Context Matters
Traditional support: In historical contexts, practitioners had teachers, communities, and frameworks.
Modern isolation: Many contemporary practitioners lack this support.
The wisdom: Intensive practice is traditionally done with guidance for good reason.
Not for Everyone
The caution: Intensive practice that might trigger dark night isn't appropriate for everyone.
The discernment: Mental health history, life stability, and support availability all matter.
The permission: Gentler practice paths exist.
What the Dark Night Isn't
Not a Requirement
The truth: Many people develop profound practice without dramatic dark nights.
The variety: Paths differ. Intense difficulty isn't the only way.
Not a Badge
The distortion: Some practitioners romanticize dark night as proof of seriousness.
The reality: Suffering isn't inherently valuable. Getting through difficult stages is; seeking them isn't.
Not an Excuse
The caution: "It's just dark night" shouldn't dismiss genuine mental illness.
The discernment: Getting proper help matters more than the label.
Not Permanent
The fear: In the midst of it, it feels endless.
The truth: It's a stage. It moves. It changes.
Prevention and Preparation
Balanced Practice
The approach: Combine insight practices with concentration, ethics, and psychological health.
The foundation: Build stability before pushing into deep territory.
Gradual Progress
The caution: Rushing development increases risk.
The patience: Let practice deepen naturally over years.
Support Systems
Before needed: Build relationships with teachers and communities before crisis.
The availability: Know where to turn if difficulties arise.
Self-Knowledge
The honesty: Know your mental health history and vulnerabilities.
The wisdom: Not everyone should do intensive practice.
Teacher Guidance
The recommendation: Don't do intensive practice without experienced guidance.
The protection: Teachers can recognize when to slow down or adjust.
The Larger View
Purification and Transformation
The understanding: Difficult stages often involve releasing old patterns, beliefs, and self-concepts.
The pain: This releasing hurts. Things don't dissolve painlessly.
The purpose: What dies makes room for what's freer.
The Other Side
What comes: Beyond dark night lie stages of peace, clarity, and freedom.
The development: Those who move through often report deeper peace than they knew before.
The worth: Whether the journey is worth it depends on the individual.
Humility About Maps
The caution: Maps are descriptions, not prescriptions. Your experience may not match neatly.
The limitation: Traditional frameworks, while useful, don't capture everything.
The individual: Your path is your path.
The Bottom Line
The dark night is a recognized phenomenon in contemplative traditions—a difficult stage that can arise through intensive practice, involving anxiety, depression, existential distress, and destabilization. It's traditionally understood as progress, not pathology, and as a stage that passes.
If you're experiencing this: - Seek support from those who understand both meditation and mental health - Adjust practice as guided - Take care of basic wellbeing - Remember it's a stage, not permanent - Don't navigate it alone
And remember: not everyone needs to go through this. Gentler paths exist. The goal is freedom, not suffering. Get the support you need, move through with care, and trust that what feels permanent isn't.
Return is a meditation timer for practitioners at all stages. If you're in difficult territory, simpler is often better—no content, no complexity, just a quiet timer for whatever practice serves you now. Download Return on the App Store.